The Blue Parakeet, 2nd Read online

  Also by Scot McKnight

  A Fellowship of Differents

  The Jesus Creed

  The King Jesus Gospel

  One.Life

  ZONDERVAN

  The Blue Parakeet

  Copyright © 2008, 2016, 2018 by Scot McKnight

  ePub Edition © April 2018: ISBN 978-0-3105-3893-6

  Requests for information should be addressed to:

  Zondervan, 3900 Sparks Dr. SE, Grand Rapids, Michigan 49546

  Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

  Names: McKnight, Scot, author.

  Title: The blue parakeet : rethinking how you read the bible / Scot McKnight.

  Description: Second edition. | Grand Rapids, MI : Zondervan, [2018] | Includes bibliographical references.

  Identifiers: LCCN 2017057361 | ISBN 9780310538929 (softcover)

  Subjects: LCSH: Bible—Hermeneutics. | Bible—Criticism, Narrative.

  Classification: LCC BS476 .M3475 2018 | DDC 220.601—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2017057361

  All Scripture quotations, unless otherwise indicated, are taken from The Holy Bible, New International Version®, NIV®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.® Used by permission of Zondervan. All rights reserved worldwide. www.Zondervan.com. The “NIV” and “New International Version” are trademarks registered in the United States Patent and Trademark Office by Biblica, Inc.®

  Other Bible versions are listed on page 271.

  Any Internet addresses (websites, blogs, etc.) and telephone numbers in this book are offered as a resource. They are not intended in any way to be or imply an endorsement by Zondervan, nor does Zondervan vouch for the content of these sites and numbers for the life of this book.

  All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means—electronic, mechanical, photocopy, recording, or any other—except for brief quotations in printed reviews, without the prior permission of the publisher.

  Published in association with the literary agency of Daniel Literary Group, LLC, 1701 Kingsbury Drive, Suite 100, Nashville, TN 37215.

  Cover design: Rob Monacelli

  Cover photo: iStockPhoto

  Interior design: Kait Lamphere

  18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 /DHV/ 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1

  Information about External Hyperlinks in this ebook

  Please note that footnotes in this ebook may contain hyperlinks to external websites as part of bibliographic citations. These hyperlinks have not been activated by the publisher, who cannot verify the accuracy of these links beyond the date of publication.

  For Cheryl Hatch

  CONTENTS

  1. The Book and I

  2. The Birds and I

  PART 1

  STORY: What Is the Bible?

  3. Inkblots and Puzzles

  4. It’s a Story with Power!

  5. The Plot of the Wiki-Stories

  PART 2

  LISTENING: What Do I Do with the Bible?

  6. From Paper to Person

  7. God Speaks, We Listen

  8. The Boring Chapter (on Missional Listening)

  PART 3

  DISCERNING: How Do I Benefit from the Bible?

  9. The Year of Living Jesus-ly

  10. Finding the Pattern of Discernment

  PART 4

  READING THE BIBLE AS STORY: Three Examples

  11. Slaves in the King and His Kingdom Redemption Story

  12. Atonement in the King and His Kingdom Redemption Story

  13. Justice in the King and His Kingdom Redemption Story

  PART 5

  Women in Church Ministries Today

  14. The Bible and Women

  15. What Did Women Do in the Old Testament?

  16. What Did Women Do in the New Testament?

  17. Silencing the Blue Parakeet (1)

  18. Silencing the Blue Parakeet (2)

  19. Now What?

  After Words

  Bible Versions

  Appendices

  Appendix 1. A Discernment Quiz

  Appendix 2. Images of Jesus

  Appendix 3. 1 Corinthians 14:34–35

  Appendix 4. Petronius on the New Roman Woman

  Appendix 5. Juvenal on First-Century Women

  Appendix 6. Junia Is Not Alone

  Appendix 7. Genesis and Science

  Notes

  CHAPTER 1

  THE BOOK AND I

  How, Then, Are We to Live the Bible Today?

  When I was in high school, I went to a Christian camp in Muscatine, Iowa, with Kris, my beautiful girlfriend (now my wife), to horse around for a week. But one morning, we were asked by our cabin leader to go spend a little time in prayer before breakfast. So I wandered out of our cabin, down a hill, alongside a basketball court, and through an open field, and then I walked over to the campfire area, climbed a short incline, and finally sat next to a tree, and prayed what my cabin leader told us to pray: “Lord, fill me with your Holy Spirit.” I wasn’t particularly open to spiritual things, but for some reason I said that prayer as our counselor advised. The Lord to whom I prayed that prayer caught me off guard. To quote the words of John Wesley, “My heart was strangely warmed.” I don’t remember what I expected to happen (probably nothing), but what happened was surprising. That prayer, or I should say the answer to that prayer, changed my life. I didn’t speak in tongues, I didn’t “see Jesus,” and I didn’t “hear God.” My eyes didn’t twitter, and I didn’t become catatonic. When I prayed, something powerful happened, and I went to breakfast a new person. Within hours I knew what I wanted to do for the rest of my life.

  On that hot summer day, I unexpectedly became a Bible student with a voracious appetite to read. Prior to that prayer I had very little interest in the Bible, and when it came to routine reading, I read only what my teachers assigned and Sports Illustrated. Within a week or two I began to read the Bible through from Genesis to Revelation, four chapters a day. I finished my reading the next spring, getting ahead of schedule because there were too many days when four chapters were not enough. My habit at the time was to arise early to read at least two chapters before going off to school, and then to read two chapters or so at night before I went to bed. I read the Scofield King James Bible, and Paul’s letter to the Galatians became my favorite book. The Bible was full of surprises for me, and my eyes, mind, and heart were stuck on wide-open wonder. All because I asked God’s Spirit to fill me.

  Some of my former Sunday school teachers were as surprised as I was by what was happening. My youth pastor encouraged me to read serious books, and he also modeled a way to study the Bible by teaching Romans to our youth group. He also suggested I learn Greek, which, because he had a spare beginning Greek grammar book, I began. I had no idea what I was doing, but I liked languages, so I plugged away, never knowing quite what to expect. My father gave me some books to read, like John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress. I devoured books. My teachers observed that I read books for class, not because I had to, but to learn and to engage in conversation.

  I had no idea what I was getting into when I asked God’s Spirit to fill me. I had no idea that I would go to college in Grand Rapids and become a bookaholic, buying books with money I didn’t have! I hung out at Eerdmans and Zondervan and Baker and Kregel looking for bargains. I knew the sales clerks by name and they knew mine. I had no idea that I would then go on to seminary and from there for doctoral studies in England (Nottingham). I had no idea how hard it might be to find a teaching position. But I have lived a privileged life, teaching at a seminary for a dozen years, undergraduates for seventeen years, and now teaching a wonderfully div
erse body of seminary students at Northern Seminary. I had no idea that I would eventually get to travel to and speak in churches around the world, that I would get to write books about Jesus and Paul and Peter and the Bible, and that I would become friends with Bible scholars all around the world. I just had no idea that teaching the Bible meant these things when I asked God’s Spirit to fill me. All I know is that from the time I was converted, I wanted to study the Bible. I’m sitting right now in my study, surrounded by books, books about the Bible, and I love what I do. I just had no idea.

  The Discovery of a Question

  Throughout this process of conversion and reading the Bible, I made discoveries that created a question that disturbed me and still does. Many of my fine Christian friends, pastors, and teachers routinely made the claim that they were Bible-believing Christians, and they were committed to the whole Bible and that—and this was one of the favorite lines—“God said it, I believe it, that settles it for me!” They were saying two things, and I add my response (which expresses my disturbance):

  One: We believe everything the Bible says, therefore . . .

  Two: We practice whatever the Bible says.

  Three: Hogwash!

  Why say “hogwash,” a tasty, salty word I learned from my father? Because I was reading the same Bible they were reading, and I observed that, in fact—emphasize that word “fact”—whatever they were claiming was not in “fact” what they were doing. (Nor was I.) What I discovered is that we all pick and choose, and I use “pick and choose” guardedly because for some picking and choosing is a license to find what they want and ignore the rest. I must confess this discovery did not discourage me as much as it disturbed me, and then it made me intensely curious (and it is why I wrote this book). The discoveries and disturbances converged onto one big question:

  How, Then, Are We to Live Out the Bible Today?

  This question never has been and never will be adequately answered with: The Bible says it, and that settles it for me. Why? Because no one does everything the Bible says. Perhaps you expected this question: How, then, are we to apply the Bible today? That’s a good question, but I think the word “apply” is a bit clinical and not as dynamic as the phrase “live out.” But we will get to that later.

  Here’s an example of my discovery process as a young student of the Bible. When you and I read the letter of James, brother of Jesus, we hear these words:

  Those who consider themselves religious and yet do not keep a tight rein on their tongues deceive themselves, and their religion is worthless. Religion that God our Father accepts as pure and faultless is this: to look after orphans and widows in their distress and to keep oneself from being polluted by the world. (James 1:26–27)

  James knew what he was talking about, and truth be told, there’s nothing hard about understanding what James said. It’s about as plain as the directions on a stop sign. The clarity of these words is the problem. For all kinds of reasons, and we’ll get to those soon, what James said had almost nothing to do with the Christian groups I knew:

  • We didn’t like the word “religious.”

  • We didn’t measure Christian maturity by control of the tongue (according to what I was hearing).

  • Pure and faultless—and that’s pretty high quality, you must admit—religion, according to James, isn’t measured by church attendance, Bible reading, witnessing, going to seminary, or anything else I found in our discipleship and church membership manuals.

  Nope. For James, a pure Christian, the kind God approves of, was one who showed compassion to orphans and widows and avoided being polluted by sin at all costs. Frankly, we emphasized the not being polluted by sin, but we defined “polluted” in ways that had nothing to do with compassion for the marginalized and suffering. For instance, we were dead set against movies, drinking wine, and sex before marriage. In our version of reality, these three were all related—if you drank with your girlfriend, you’d lose your senses and go to a movie and end up having sex. I’m not only making fun of my past, I’m emphasizing how distorted things got—a good, solid Christian was one who didn’t do specific things that were against the rules. It also had to do with what we did—which was go to church weekly, read the Bible daily, and witness as often as we could. These aren’t bad things; in fact, I learned to love the Bible because of this context. But the one thing we didn’t do was follow everything James said!

  As I kept looking around me, this began to disturb me. How in the world were we reading the same Bible? One thing was clear, and it was irony: we were all reading the Bible the same way and that meant we had somehow learned not to follow the plain words of James!

  What I learned was an uncomfortable but incredibly intriguing truth: Every one of us adopts the Bible and (at the same time) adapts the Bible to our culture. In less appreciated terms, I’ll put it this way: Everyone picks and chooses. I know this sounds out of the box and off the wall for many, but no matter how hard we try to convince ourselves otherwise, it’s true. We pick and choose. (It’s easier for us to hear “we adopt and adapt,” but the two expressions amount to the same thing.)

  I believe many of us want to know why we pick and choose. Even more importantly, many of us want to know how to do this in a way that honors God and embraces the Bible as God’s Word for all times. We’ll get to that. First, I offer some examples of picking and choosing or “adopting and adapting.”

  Picking and Choosing

  Sabbath

  The Bible I read both instituted and did not appear to back down from the Sabbath. Observing the Sabbath meant not working from Friday night to Saturday night (Exodus 20:9–10), and I found numerous references in the Acts of the Apostles to the Christian observance of Sabbath. But as I was learning how to read the Bible inside a bundle of serious-minded Christians, I knew no one who really practiced the Sabbath. I quickly learned that the Christian Sunday, which focuses on fellowship and worship, is not the same as the Jewish Sabbath, which focuses on rest from labor. (You can read about this in any good Bible dictionary or on Wikipedia.) The Sabbath was described in the Bible, and it wasn’t a “that settles it for me!” for anyone I knew.

  What really got me going was that nobody seemed interested in this question. Yes, I did hear that some thought a passage like Colossians 2:16 may—but only may—have given gentiles permission not to keep Sabbath, but the issue was not crystal clear. I was learning in my days of youth that we sometimes, rightly or wrongly, live out the Bible by not doing something in the Bible!1

  Tithing

  The Bible I read taught tithing, but the Bible does not insist that all of the tithe must go to a local church. Truth be told, the New Testament doesn’t even bring up the tithe. In the Bible the tithe is a combination of spiritual support (for the temple) and social service (for the poor). Moses says tithes are to be given not only to the Levites (roughly the temple servants) but also to the alien, to the fatherless, and to the widow (Deuteronomy 26:12). We are back to James’s “orphans and widows.” The churches I was attending had nothing to do with immigrants, did little to help orphans, and so far as I knew did little to strengthen widows.

  What was more, the tithe we were hearing about was something we were to give to our local church for buildings, maintenance, pastoral salaries, missionaries, and the like. But the Bible said that I—as a tither—was to give some of my tithe to the Levite and also to those who were marginalized and suffering. This was something neither I nor anyone I knew was doing. I was learning that we sometimes live out the Bible, rightly or wrongly, by morphing one thing into another, that is, by taking a tithe for temple assistants and also for the poor and turning it into a tithe for the local church. It might be fine to read the Bible like this, but we should at least admit what we are doing: in a word, we are morphing.

  Foot Washing

  Another discovery I made was that Jesus explicitly commanded foot washing in John 13:14. Widows who received benefits from the church were known as those who had washed the feet
of saints (1 Timothy 5:10). St. Augustine, three and a half centuries later, writes about Christians washing the feet of the freshly baptized, so I knew that the practice continued well beyond the New Testament days. But I was surrounded by Bible believers and had never seen this happen. I learned that some Christians still practice this, but no one I knew (except a high school friend’s church) was doing it. We were either ignoring what the Bible taught or morphing it into a cultural parallel like hanging up one another’s coats and offering our guests something to drink. A New Testament scholar, Bill Mounce, in his exhaustive study of 1 Timothy, draws this conclusion about what Paul says of widows: “Paul is not asking if the widow followed church ritual [i.e., whether she physically washed feet]; he is asking if she was the type of person who had done good deeds throughout her life.”2 In other words, Paul is not speaking of something literal—real washing of feet—but of an underlying principle—serving others. What I learned is that sometimes we look behind the text to grasp a timeless principle, and the principle is more important than doing the actual words.

  Bill Mounce might be right, but my question as a college student was this one: “How did we know Paul’s words were really only describing a symptom of a person of good deeds instead of a literal requirement?” Some suggested to me to quit asking such pesky questions and just follow along, but inside I was learning to pursue what for me has been a lifelong, joyous ride of exploring how we live out the Bible.

  Charismatic Gifts

  The more I became aware of the rise of the charismatic movement, the more I discovered Jesus, Paul, and Peter had the power to work miracles (Matthew 4:23; 10:8; Acts 4:1–12; 16:16–18). In my first year of Bible reading I learned that Christians in Paul’s churches gave words of prophecy (1 Corinthians 12–14). And I knew Jesus said that his followers would do even greater things than he did. No one that I knew was doing miracles or giving words of prophecy. What I learned from this experience is an expression that sums up the way many read the Bible: “That was then, but this is now.”